An American teacher in Nantes has invested for ten years in a world equity fund recommended by her bank, through a securities account and a PEA. In France, she has done everything right. When she sells, her American return treats the gain as if it had been earned evenly over ten years, taxes each year's share at the highest American rate applicable that year, and adds interest as if the tax had been due all along. Her best-performing savings becomes her most heavily taxed.
This article explains why French and European funds fall under the American regime for passive foreign investment companies, how the three possible regimes work, why the French and American tax calendars do not align, and how to get out. The specific treatment of funds held within an assurance-vie contract is covered in our analysis of assurance-vie.
I. What a PFIC is, and why French funds almost always are
A. Two tests: passive income and passive assets
A foreign corporation is a passive foreign investment company if 75% or more of its gross income is passive income, or if at least 50% of its assets, on average, produce or are held to produce passive income (IRC, section 1297). Dividends, interest and gains on securities are passive income. An investment fund, whose purpose is precisely to hold securities, meets both tests by construction.
B. French and European funds
SICAVs and European exchange-traded funds organized as companies are foreign corporations for American tax purposes, and therefore PFICs. French FCPs, which have no legal personality, raise a classification question under the American entity classification rules; in practice they are most often treated as PFICs, and any other position must be documented fund by fund. The wrapper does not change the analysis: a fund held through an ordinary securities account, a PEA or a company savings plan remains a PFIC, and so do the funds held within an assurance-vie contract if the contract itself is treated as transparent.
C. What is not a PFIC
Shares of operating companies are not PFICs: a French or European listed company whose income comes from an industrial or commercial business does not meet the tests. This is the key to the way out: an American in France can hold European equities directly without entering the regime, whereas the same exposure through a fund triggers it. The look-through rule, which attributes to a company its share of the assets and income of companies in which it holds at least 25%, can however make an apparently operating holding company a PFIC.
II. The three regimes
A. The default regime: the gain spread over time, with interest
Absent an election, the gain on the sale of PFIC shares, and the fraction of any distribution exceeding 125% of the average of the three previous years, are treated as excess distributions (IRC, section 1291). The amount is spread evenly over each day of the holding period. The share allocated to the current year is ordinary income; the shares allocated to previous years are taxed at the highest rate applicable in each of those years, plus interest as if the tax had been due then. The preferential rate on long-term capital gains never applies. Each PFIC is treated separately: the Tax Court held in Toso v. Commissioner (2018) that gains on some PFICs cannot be offset by losses on others. For a fund held for ten years with a significant gain, the combined effect can far exceed the normal rate on capital gains.
B. The qualified electing fund: effective, but rarely possible
The investor may elect to treat the fund as a qualified electing fund, in which case he includes each year his share of its ordinary income and net capital gain, with the capital gains character preserved. This election, which neutralizes the regime, requires the fund to provide each year an annual information statement in the American format. French asset managers almost never provide it, which makes this route theoretical for most French funds.
C. The mark-to-market election
For marketable shares, that is, shares regularly traded on a qualifying exchange, the investor may elect to include each year, as ordinary income, the increase in value of the shares, the election being made on Form 8621 (IRS, Instructions for Form 8621). The regime is simpler and avoids the interest charge, at the cost of taxing unrealized gains every year at ordinary rates. It suits European exchange-traded funds listed on a qualifying exchange, but not unlisted French funds. If the election is made after the first year of holding, the default regime applies to the year of the election unless the past is first purged.
III. The mismatch with French tax
A. Two calendars
France taxes the gain on a fund when the investor sells or redeems his units (CGI, art. 150-0 A), and the PEA exempts gains from income tax after five years, subject to social levies. The United States, under the mark-to-market election, taxes the increase in value every year; under the default regime, it taxes at sale but as if the gain had been earned each year. The two systems therefore tax the same gain at different times, and sometimes one taxes what the other exempts.
B. What the foreign tax credit catches up, and what it does not
For an American resident in France, gains on French funds are taxable in France, and the United States grants a credit for the French tax, the treaty treating this income as French-source for that purpose (convention of 31 August 1994, art. 24). But the credit only offsets tax paid on the same income, in the same category, within its carryover periods. Under the mark-to-market election, the American tax falls each year while the French tax falls only at sale: the credit arrives late and only partially catches up, through its one-year carryback and ten-year carryforward. Within a PEA held more than five years, there is no French income tax to credit at all: the American tax remains in full. And the favourable mechanism for American-source dividends and gains that we described in our analysis of US brokerage accounts does not apply, since French funds are not American-source.
IV. Reporting and the way out
A. Form 8621
A separate Form 8621 must be filed for each PFIC, each year (IRS, Form 8621). The form carries the elections and the calculations of each regime. A de minimis exception dispenses with the filing when the total value of the investor's PFIC shares does not exceed 25,000 dollars at year-end (50,000 dollars for a joint return), provided that he received no excess distribution, realized no gain and made no election. The omission has no fixed penalty, but it keeps the assessment period open for the entire return of the year, as we explained in our FBAR inventory.
B. The way out: purge, then reorganize
Three steps. First, regularize the past: an American in France who never filed his Forms 8621 must include them in his regularization, typically through the streamlined procedure, with the calculations of the default regime. Second, purge the existing positions: either sell the funds and accept the cost of the default regime once, at the least unfavourable moment, or make a deemed sale election to switch to the mark-to-market regime for listed ETFs. Third, reorganize future savings: hold European equities directly rather than through funds, use the mark-to-market election for any listed ETF that is kept, and consider American-domiciled funds held through an American broker, whose access for European residents is however limited by European investor information rules and by some brokers' policies.
Conclusion
For an American living in France, French and European investment funds are almost always passive foreign investment companies. The default regime spreads the gain over the holding period, taxes it at the highest rates and adds interest, without offsetting losses; the qualified electing fund election is effective but rarely available for French funds; the mark-to-market election works for listed ETFs at the cost of taxing unrealized gains every year. France taxes the same gains later, or not at all in a mature PEA, so that the foreign tax credit only partially restores balance.
The practical rule follows: identify every PFIC, regularize the Forms 8621, purge the existing positions at the least costly moment, and rebuild savings around directly held equities and, where appropriate, listed ETFs under the mark-to-market election. The worst strategy is the most common one: continuing to save like a French investor while filing like an American who has never heard of PFICs.
Frequently asked questions
I am American and live in France. Are my French investment funds PFICs?
Almost always. A foreign corporation is a PFIC if 75% of its income is passive or 50% of its assets are passive, which describes any investment fund. SICAVs and European ETFs organized as companies are PFICs; French FCPs raise a classification question but are most often treated the same way. Shares of operating companies held directly, on the other hand, are not PFICs.
How is a PFIC taxed when I sell it?
Under the default regime, the gain is spread over each day of the holding period; the part allocated to prior years is taxed at the highest rate of each of those years, plus interest, and the part allocated to the current year is ordinary income. The capital gains rate never applies, and the Tax Court held in Toso (2018) that losses on one PFIC cannot offset gains on another.
Can I avoid this regime?
Partly. The qualified electing fund election neutralizes it but requires an annual information statement that French funds almost never provide. The mark-to-market election is available for listed ETFs and taxes each year's increase in value as ordinary income. The most effective solution is to hold equities directly rather than through funds, after purging existing positions.
Do I have to file Form 8621 for each fund?
Yes, one per PFIC and per year, unless the total value of your PFIC shares does not exceed 25,000 dollars at year-end (50,000 dollars for a joint return) and you received no excess distribution, realized no gain and made no election. A missing Form 8621 carries no fixed penalty but keeps the assessment period open for the entire return of the year.




