Russia, Cyprus, Switzerland, Monaco: a tax treaty only protects a non-resident if its wording allows it, and the French Supreme Court now reads it through French law.
A Russian tax resident wholly owns a Cypriot company. That company owns two Swiss companies and 5% of two French property companies (sociétés civiles immobilières, SCI), the remaining 95% of which belong to his daughter. All these companies own real estate in France. Having reported his Cypriot shareholding for the former French wealth tax, the taxpayer sought a refund: in his view, the France-Russia tax treaty only allowed France to tax shares in companies whose assets mainly consist of real estate, and his Cypriot company, holding just 5% of the French companies, did not qualify. In a ruling of 6 May 2026, published in its official reports, the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) disagreed: the treaty concept of a real estate rich company is read through French law, including its family holding rules.
The issue goes well beyond this case. For a non-resident who holds French real estate through a chain of companies, the tax treaty is often presented as a shield. How far does it actually protect, when the court refers to domestic law to interpret its terms? Our analysis is as follows: treaty protection depends entirely on the treaty's wording. A treaty with no specific clause on real estate companies can protect effectively; a treaty with such a clause but no definition opens the door to all the extensive rules of French law. And a suspended treaty, like the France-Russia treaty since 2023, no longer protects at all.
We first recall how France taxes non-residents on French real estate (I), then the solution and reach of the ruling of 6 May 2026 (II). We then compare the situations in which a treaty does or does not protect (III), before drawing the consequences for the real estate wealth tax (IFI) and for structuring holdings (IV).
I. How does France tax real estate held by non-residents?
A. The real estate wealth tax: a look-through tax
Since 1 January 2018, the real estate wealth tax (impôt sur la fortune immobilière, IFI) applies to individuals whose taxable real estate assets exceed EUR 1,300,000 on 1 January. Persons not domiciled in France for tax purposes are liable on real estate located in France and on shares in companies to the extent of the fraction of their value representing such property (French General Tax Code, CGI, art. 964, 2°). Holding through companies, French or foreign, therefore does not take the property out of the scope of the tax.
A real estate ratio applied to each holding. Article 965 of the CGI organises this look-through: the value of the shares is taken in proportion to the ratio between the market value of the taxable real estate held directly or indirectly by the company and the value of all its assets. The provision excludes holdings below 10% in operating companies, as well as property used in an industrial, commercial, craft, agricultural or professional activity, but brings back property of companies the taxpayer controls or reserves the use of. Value is determined under the rules applying to inheritance tax, and certain intra-group or family debts are not deductible (CGI, art. 973).
B. Under the former wealth tax and for transfers: the family holding rule
Under the former wealth tax (impôt de solidarité sur la fortune, ISF), which applied until 2017, the logic was different. Non-residents were taxed on their assets located in France, and the tax was assessed under the same rules as inheritance tax. That reference led to Article 750 ter, 2°, of the CGI, which still governs the territorial scope of French gift and inheritance tax where the donor or deceased is not domiciled in France.
A presumption of family holding. Under that provision, a property is deemed held indirectly where it belongs to companies in which the donor or deceased, alone or jointly with their spouse, their ascendants or descendants or their siblings, holds more than half of the rights, directly or through a chain of holdings within the meaning of Article 990 D of the CGI. The same provision treats as French the shares of unlisted foreign companies whose assets mainly consist of real estate located in France, in proportion to the value of that property within total assets. It is this mechanism, and not the IFI rules, that the French Supreme Court relied on in 2026.
II. The ruling of 6 May 2026: the treaty concept read through French law
A. The taxpayer's arguments
The taxpayer argued that a tax treaty prevails over domestic law and must be applied strictly and literally. Article 22(2) of the France-Russia treaty allowed France to tax capital represented by shares in a company whose assets mainly consist, directly or through the interposition of other companies, of real estate located in France. In his view, his Cypriot company only held 5% of the two French property companies; their property could only enter its assets up to that 5%, and the treaty contained no mechanism for aggregating family holdings. He also challenged the exclusion of his current account receivable from the Cypriot company's movable assets, and the fact that relief had been made conditional on proof of taxation in Russia (Cass. com., 6 May 2026, No. 24-22.185, para. 5).
B. The solution: a reference to domestic law, family rules included
The French Supreme Court dismissed the appeal. It noted that the concept of a company whose assets are mainly real estate is not defined by the treaty, and that Article 3(2) of the treaty provides that any undefined term has the meaning it has under the law of the applying State, tax law prevailing over other branches of law. Since no contextual element, in particular in the protocol, required a different interpretation, the concept had to be understood under French law (same ruling, paras. 7 and 8).
The Article 750 ter rules read into the treaty. The Court concluded that the treaty concept must have the meaning given to it by paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 of Article 750 ter, 2°, of the CGI and, by cross-reference, by Article 990 D (para. 14). In practice, the property held by the French companies of which the Cypriot company held only 5% could be taken into account beyond that share, since the taxpayer and his daughter together held more than half of their capital. The other limbs of the appeal, which relied solely on a breach of Article 22 of the treaty (current account, proof of Russian taxation), were held ineffective (para. 15).
C. Reach: the treaty is no longer an autonomous shield
The ruling, published in the official reports, reaches beyond the France-Russia treaty. It sets a method: where a treaty refers to real estate rich companies without defining them, the civil courts determine their content by reference to French tax law, including where that law aggregates the holdings of the taxpayer's family. The literal reading of the treaty, which would have taken into account only the rights actually held by the interposed company, is rejected. This may come as a surprise, since the treaty itself deals with interposed companies; it nonetheless fits a trend towards systematically anchoring treaty characterisations in domestic law.
III. When does a treaty still protect a non-resident?
A. Treaties without a real estate clause: the 2015 solution
A 2015 ruling of the Court's plenary assembly shows why the wording test matters. A Moroccan national domiciled in Monaco held 41.58% of a Monegasque civil company that owned numerous properties in France. On his death, the French tax authorities included those shares in the estate taxable in France. The plenary assembly held that, under the France-Monaco inheritance tax treaty of 1 April 1950, the shares in the Monegasque company were movable property governed by its Article 6, not immovable property governed by its Article 2: since the deceased was domiciled in Monaco, they were taxable only in Monaco (Cass., plenary assembly, 2 Oct. 2015, No. 14-14.256).
A difference in wording, not in method. The two rulings do not contradict each other. In 2015, the Monaco treaty contained a specific rule for shares and no clause on real estate rich companies; the immovable property category of Article 2 could not therefore absorb company shares. The reasons adopted from the Court of Appeal, approved by the plenary assembly, also noted that other treaties, such as the France-Italy inheritance treaty of 20 December 1990, expressly contain such a clause. In 2026, the France-Russia treaty contained one, but without a definition: the reference to domestic law then worked against the taxpayer.
B. The France-Russia treaty: a suspended protection
For Russian residents, the issue has taken on another dimension. By a presidential decree of 8 August 2023, the Russian Federation suspended the application of Articles 5 to 22 and 24 of the treaty of 26 November 1996, as well as points 2 to 9 of its protocol. On a reciprocal basis, France suspended the same provisions from the same date (notice published in the French Official Journal). Article 22, on capital, is among the suspended provisions.
Consequences for IFI. The French tax authorities state that assets held on 1 January 2023 remain taxable under Article 22 of the treaty, but that the treaty ceases to apply for tax years from 1 January 2024; real estate wealth is now subject to domestic law alone. They add that taxes levied by Russia on assets affected by the suspension give rise to no tax credit in France, and that Russia has been on the French list of non-cooperative States and territories since 2024 (BOI-INT-CVB-RUS-20241023, paras. 110, 260 and 270). For a Russian resident holding French real estate, the 2026 ruling therefore matters mainly for past years: for recent years, the treaty question no longer arises.
C. A reading grid for other treaties
For a non-resident of another State, the analysis must start from the text of the applicable treaty. Three situations can be distinguished. If the treaty does not cover taxes on capital, it offers no protection against IFI. If it covers them without a specific clause on real estate companies, company shares may fall under the rule for other capital, often exclusive taxation in the State of residence, provided nothing else in the text points the other way. If it contains a clause on real estate rich companies without defining it, the 2026 ruling leads to applying the French tax law definition, with its look-through rules and, where relevant, family aggregation. The protocol and any exchange of letters must be read with the same care, since the French Supreme Court looks for any contextual element requiring a different interpretation.
IV. What consequences for IFI and for structuring holdings?
A. An uncertain transposition to IFI
The ruling concerned the former wealth tax, assessed under inheritance tax rules, which justified recourse to Article 750 ter. IFI rests on a different structure: its base is defined by Articles 964 and 965 of the CGI, and only the value of assets is determined under inheritance tax rules (Article 973). Article 965 only covers the assets of the taxpayer, their spouse or partner and their minor children; it does not contain the Article 750 ter rule aggregating the holdings of adult descendants, ascendants and siblings.
Our reading. For a treaty that covers IFI and refers to real estate rich companies without defining them, the reference to domestic law should, in our view, lead to the IFI rules, since the treaty gives priority to the meaning given by tax law concerning the taxes to which it applies. The family aggregation of Article 750 ter should therefore not be transposed automatically to IFI. The point remains open, however, and the tax authorities could argue for a broader reading. For gifts and inheritances by non-residents, on the other hand, Article 750 ter applies directly: the 2026 reasoning carries over fully to inheritance treaties containing a real estate clause.
B. A method for auditing holdings
For a non-resident holding French real estate through companies, the audit should proceed in four steps. First, identify the applicable treaty, check that it covers the tax at issue (IFI, gift or inheritance tax) and that it is not suspended. Second, check whether it contains a clause on real estate rich companies and whether it defines it. Third, map the entire holding chain, including holdings of the spouse, children and other family members, since they may tip the characterisation. Fourth, compute the real estate ratio of each company, taking into account the exclusions for property used in a business and the non-deductibility rules for certain debts.
Intra-group financing. In the 2026 case, the French companies' property acquisitions had been financed by a current account from the Cypriot company, which the Court of Appeal had excluded from its movable assets, and the French Supreme Court did not examine that complaint on the merits. Current accounts and family or intra-group loans used to acquire property should therefore be analysed with care, both for the real estate ratio and, under IFI, in light of the non-deductibility rules of Article 973.
C. The firm's position
We are convinced that a tax treaty is not a generic shield but a text in which every word counts. Non-residents' real estate holdings structured through foreign companies should be reviewed in light of three questions: does the treaty cover the tax at issue and is it applicable; does it contain a real estate clause; and does the taxpayer's family together hold more than half of the property companies? For Russian residents, the suspension of the treaty requires reasoning under domestic law alone for tax years from 2024.
Before any IFI return or any transfer, we recommend an audit of the holding chain and of the applicable treaty. We have set out the general rules for non-residents owning property in France and the options for structuring French real estate held by non-residents; the 2026 ruling requires adding a careful reading of each treaty.
Conclusion
The ruling of 6 May 2026 confirms that treaty protection for non-residents depends on the wording of each treaty. Where a treaty refers to real estate rich companies without defining them, the French Supreme Court applies the French law definition, including the Article 750 ter rule aggregating family holdings. Conversely, a treaty without a real estate clause may lead to treating company shares as movable property taxable in the State of residence, as the plenary assembly held in 2015.
We are convinced that treaty analysis must come before any structuring and any filing. For IFI, the transposition of the 2026 reasoning remains uncertain, since Article 965 has no comparable family aggregation rule; for gifts and inheritances by non-residents, it is direct. For Russian residents, the suspension of the treaty has removed treaty protection since IFI 2024.
We recommend that any non-resident holding French real estate through companies commission a combined audit of the holding chain and the applicable treaty. Its cost bears no comparison with French taxation of holdings that were thought to be protected by a treaty.
Frequently asked questions
Is a non-resident liable to French IFI on shares in French property companies?
Yes. Article 964 of the French tax code makes persons not domiciled in France liable to IFI on their real estate located in France and on shares in companies to the extent of the fraction of their value representing such property, where their taxable assets exceed EUR 1,300,000 on 1 January. Holding through interposed foreign companies does not prevent this. A tax treaty may, however, limit France's taxing right, depending on its wording.
Can a tax treaty protect a non-resident against French wealth tax?
It depends on its wording. Where the treaty has no specific clause on real estate rich companies, shares may be treated as movable property taxable in the State of residence, as the plenary assembly of the French Supreme Court held in 2015 under the France-Monaco inheritance treaty. Where the treaty contains such a clause without defining it, the French Supreme Court applies French law, which may widen French taxation.
Are the children's holdings taken into account to assess whether a company is real estate rich?
For the former wealth tax and gift and inheritance tax, yes: under Article 750 ter of the French tax code, a property is deemed held indirectly where the taxpayer, alone or with their spouse, ascendants, descendants or siblings, holds more than half of the company's rights. In May 2026 the French Supreme Court read this rule into the treaty concept of a real estate rich company. For IFI, Article 965 only covers the taxpayer's household and minor children, which makes the transposition uncertain.
Can a Russian resident still rely on the France-Russia treaty for IFI?
Not for tax years from 2024 onwards. Russia suspended, from 8 August 2023, several articles of the treaty, including Article 22 on capital, and France did the same on a reciprocal basis. According to the French tax authorities, assets held on 1 January 2023 still fall under the treaty, but IFI is then governed by domestic law alone, with no tax credit for Russian tax.



