Alphard Law, a Paris tax law firm, advises families whose estate has a cross-border element: a deceased or heirs living outside France, assets located abroad, a foreign will, a trust or an interposed company. A cross-border estate follows two logics that must be handled separately. Civil law determines who inherits and in what proportions; tax law determines which state levies duties, on which assets and at what rate. The two questions are governed by different criteria and frequently point to different countries. That is why planning ahead is decisive and improvisation expensive.
Who inherits? The applicable law under the EU Succession Regulation
For deaths occurring on or after 17 August 2015, the law governing the estate is determined by Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of 4 July 2012. The principle is straightforward: the law applicable to the succession as a whole is that of the state in which the deceased had their habitual residence at the time of death (Art. 21). An escape clause allows that law to be set aside where the deceased was manifestly more closely connected with another state.
Any person may, however, choose the law of the state whose nationality they possess, at the time of the choice or at the time of death, to govern their succession as a whole (Art. 22). The choice must be made in a disposition of property upon death, in practice a will. The law designated applies even if it is not the law of a Member State (Art. 20): a French national living in Dubai, Singapore or the United States may therefore submit their estate to French law, or conversely find it governed by a foreign law that knows no forced heirship.
The Regulation expressly excludes tax matters from its scope (Art. 1). A choice of law organises the civil devolution of the estate; it changes nothing on the tax side, which is governed by each state's own tax law. We advise never to draft a choice-of-law clause without quantifying, in parallel, the tax charge it leaves in place.
Who taxes? The three cases of Article 750 ter of the French Tax Code
In France, the territorial scope of inheritance tax is set by Article 750 ter of the French Tax Code (Code général des impôts, CGI). It provides for three cases, assessed by reference to tax domicile as defined in Article 4 B CGI, regardless of nationality.
| Situation | Assets taxable in France |
|---|---|
| 1. The deceased was tax domiciled in France | All assets, wherever located |
| 2. The deceased was not domiciled in France | French-situs assets only, including French real estate held indirectly through a company more than half owned by the family |
| 3. The heir is domiciled in France at the time of the transfer and has been for at least six of the last ten years | All assets the heir receives, wherever located and whatever the deceased's domicile |
The third case is the one that most often surprises families. It requires two cumulative conditions: the heir must be domiciled in France when they receive the assets, and must have been so for at least six of the preceding ten years. A child who has moved back to Paris may therefore be taxed in France on foreign assets inherited from a parent who never lived in France. Conversely, an heir who settled abroad before the death falls outside this criterion, even after a long period of French residence.
The second case calls for particular care from non-residents owning a flat in France, directly or through a property company: interposing a company, even a foreign one, does not take the property outside the scope of French tax under the conditions laid down by the statute. We set out the consequences in our study on French real estate for non-residents.
How much? Rates, allowances and exemptions
Duties are calculated on the net share passing to each heir, after a personal allowance, under the scale of Article 777 CGI. The main parameters currently in force are as follows.
- Surviving spouse and PACS partner: full exemption from inheritance tax (Article 796-0 bis CGI).
- Children and parents: allowance of €100,000 per parent and per child (Article 779 CGI), then a progressive scale from 5% to 45%, with 20% on the band between €15,932 and €552,324 and 45% above €1,805,677.
- Siblings: allowance of €15,932, then 35% up to €24,430 and 45% above.
- Nephews and nieces: allowance of €7,967, then 55%.
- Relatives beyond the fourth degree and unrelated persons: 60%.
These allowances and rates apply in the same way whether the heir lives in France or abroad: the heir's residence affects the scope of the tax, not its rate. The 60% rate between unrelated persons explains why blended and international families benefit from planning that integrates life insurance and lifetime gifts.
How can double taxation be avoided?
The same estate may be taxed by two states: France under one of the three cases of Article 750 ter, and the state of the deceased's residence or of the assets' location under its own rules. Inheritance tax treaties, far fewer than income tax treaties, generally allocate taxing rights according to two criteria: the domicile of the deceased and the location of the assets, real estate usually being taxable in the state where it is situated (BOI-INT-DG-20-20-90). The France-United States treaty is one example, which we analyse in our study on US heirs of French estates.
Absent a treaty, French domestic law offers a limited remedy. Article 784 A CGI allows, in the first and third cases of Article 750 ter, a credit against French tax for duties paid abroad, but only up to the tax paid on assets located outside France. Foreign duties levied on French-situs assets are never creditable. Residual double taxation is common; it is addressed upstream, through the structuring of the estate and the choice of transfer instruments, and far less easily once the estate has opened.
Non-resident heirs: is a French inheritance tax return required?
Yes, as soon as the estate falls within the scope of French tax. Article 800 CGI requires heirs and legatees to file a detailed return. Direct-line heirs, the surviving spouse and the PACS partner are exempt where the gross estate is below €50,000 and they have not previously received an undeclared gift from the deceased; for other heirs the threshold is €3,000.
The filing deadline is six months from death where the deceased died in metropolitan France, and one year in all other cases, in particular where the death occurs abroad (Article 641 CGI). Late filing triggers late-payment interest and, beyond that, penalties. For an heir living abroad the difficulty is rarely the form itself: it lies in determining the taxable base (which assets fall within French scope), valuing foreign assets and evidencing duties paid outside France. These are the three points on which our involvement adds value, in coordination with the notary administering the estate.
Trusts and foreign structures: a regime of their own
Transfers of assets held in a trust are governed by Article 792-0 bis CGI. Where the transfer cannot be characterised as a gift or an inheritance, assets remaining in the trust on the settlor's death are taxed according to the family relationship if the beneficiary's share is determined, at 45% where a share is due globally to the settlor's descendants, and at 60% on the balance. The trustee is also subject to the reporting obligations of Article 1649 AB CGI. A trust that is perfectly regular in its home jurisdiction may therefore produce French consequences its drafters never contemplated. We cover this regime in our French tax guide to foreign trusts and foundations for heirs.
Our role: plan, administer, defend
Plan. The firm acts upstream, while every option remains open: choice of applicable law by will, articulation between French and foreign dispositions, gifts and split ownership, Dutreil arrangements for business transfers, life insurance taken out in France or abroad, and consistency of the whole with the matrimonial property regime, often the primary source of disorder in international families. We quantify the expected tax charge in each relevant jurisdiction before any decision is taken.
Administer. Where the death has occurred, we assist heirs with the French inheritance tax return, the determination of the taxable base in the presence of foreign assets, the credit for duties paid abroad, the treatment of trusts and foreign companies, and coordination with the French notary and local counsel. Estates including assets the deceased had not reported call for specific treatment, set out on our voluntary disclosure of foreign assets page.
Defend. French inheritance tax reassessments fall within the judicial courts, not the administrative ones: a preliminary claim, then the tribunal judiciaire, the court of appeal and the commercial chamber of the Cour de cassation. The most frequent grounds are the valuation of assets and unlisted shares, challenges to Dutreil arrangements, territoriality and the treatment of foreign structures. Our practice in these disputes is set out on our tax litigation page.
We work systematically with the family's notary, whose role is central to the civil administration of the estate, and with vetted local counsel in the jurisdictions concerned, while retaining responsibility for the coherence of the whole. Every matter produces a written, sourced analysis delivered to the family, documenting the choices made and their rationale.
Our insights on cross-border estates
Frequently asked questions
Which law applies to my estate if I live abroad?
In principle, the law of the state of your habitual residence at the time of death, under the EU Succession Regulation, unless you have chosen the law of your nationality by will. That choice determines, among other things, whether forced heirship applies. It settles nothing on the tax side, which the Regulation excludes from its scope.
Will my heirs pay French inheritance tax if I no longer live in France?
Yes on your French-situs assets, including real estate held through a company. On your assets located abroad, French duties are due only from an heir who is domiciled in France at the time of the transfer and has been for at least six of the last ten years. Each heir must therefore be analysed separately.
I live abroad: do I need to file a French inheritance tax return?
Yes, where the estate includes assets taxable in France, unless the gross estate is below €50,000 for direct-line heirs, the spouse or the PACS partner, or below €3,000 for other heirs. The deadline is six months from death where it occurs in metropolitan France, and one year in all other cases.
Is there double taxation on cross-border estates?
Yes, and it is frequent, because inheritance tax treaties are few. Absent a treaty, France allows a credit for duties paid abroad, but only against the tax on assets located outside France. Foreign duties levied on French-situs assets are not creditable.
How is a trust treated in a French estate?
Assets held in a trust are subject to a regime of their own, which taxes the beneficiary according to their relationship with the settlor where their share is determined and otherwise applies rates of 45% or 60%. The trustee is also subject to specific reporting obligations.
Do I need a lawyer in addition to the notary?
The French notary is indispensable to the civil administration of the estate; that is their office. A tax lawyer addresses international tax strategy, the articulation of several legal systems, the treatment of foreign structures and defence in the event of an audit. As soon as a border is involved, the two professions complement each other, and we work routinely with our clients' notaries.
References
- Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012, Arts. 1, 20, 21, 22 and 83 (EUR-Lex)
- French Tax Code (CGI), Arts. 4 B, 641, 750 ter, 777, 779, 784 A, 792-0 bis, 796-0 bis, 800 and 1649 AB (Légifrance)
- BOI-INT-DG-20-20-90-20121231: tax treaties on gift and inheritance duties (BOFiP)
Does your estate have an international dimension? Contact Alphard Law for a confidential initial discussion.